Bay Shore’s waterfront jewel prepares for a new chapter as its beloved steward steps away, leaving a legacy tied to the bay’s timeless beauty.
Stand on the edge of the Great South Bay, where the water catches the last light of day, and you’ll feel it: the magic of Nicky’s on the Bay, a place that owes its heart to Nick “Nicky” Parini. For years, Nicky made this waterfront haven a cornerstone of Bay Shore, a spot where the view alone could steal your breath. As he steps back from the restaurant that bears his name, our community pauses to honor a man whose vision turned a slice of shoreline into a Long Island legend. With a summer reopening looming, we bid Nicky goodbye, knowing the bay will always whisper his story.
The Man Who Framed the Bay’s Beauty
Nicky Parini didn’t just own a restaurant—he gave Bay Shore a front-row seat to paradise. From the city’s hum to the Hamptons’ glow, Nicky’s on the Bay drew crowds chasing one thing: that view. Picture yourself on the observation deck, the bay stretching endless before you, sailboats bobbing under a sky streaked with fire. Nicky knew the real star was the location—a waterfront perch that felt like a secret escape. He built a place where the lapping waves and salty breeze made every moment feel alive, earning him a special place in the hearts of locals who call him one of their own.
A Legacy Woven into the Waves
Nicky’s on the Bay is more than a spot on the map—it’s Bay Shore’s soul, shaped by Nicky’s love for this stretch of coast. He created a gathering place where life unfolded: proposals sealed with a sunset, birthdays toasted under the stars, or quiet evenings where the water’s calm washed worries away. The sprawling deck offered panoramic views that could hush any crowd, while the 100-foot floating dock—ready for 22 boats—beckoned adventurers to tie up and soak it in. Nicky’s genius was letting the bay shine, turning his restaurant into a stage for Long Island’s natural splendor.
Locals share tales of his warmth, visitors recall the spell of that shoreline, and everyone feels the pull of a place that’s pure Bay Shore. As Nicky steps away, his absence stings, but his gift—this unbeatable location—anchors us still.
Jones Hollow Realty Group: Carrying Nicky’s Light
As Nicky passes his vision to new hands, Jones Hollow Realty Group is honored to have paved the way. Deeply tied to Long Island’s spirit, we specialize in guiding landmarks like Nicky’s into their next chapter with care. The sale was handled quietly, ensuring the place Nicky made iconic could keep its place on the bay.
A shout-out to Shauna Joli, a Jones Hollow Realty Group licensed salesperson, whose skill and dedication ensured a seamless transition. Her work ensures Nicky’s on the Bay will continue to dazzle, a fitting tribute to the man who made it unforgettable.
To Nicky, With Gratitude
It’s hard to imagine Nicky’s on the Bay without Nicky’s steady presence, but as summer brings a fresh start, we know this spot will hold his essence. The deck will still frame those heart-stopping sunsets. The dock will still welcome boats with a promise of adventure. The bay will still shimmer, just as Nicky always let it.
Here’s to you, Nicky Parini—Bay Shore’s north star, who saw the beauty in a waterfront view and shared it with us all. As we cheer your next journey, we’ll gather again at Nicky’s, watching the waves and raising a glass to you. Thank you, from every corner of our community.
Got your own Long Island vision?
Jones Hollow Realty Group is ready to make it real. Call 833-GO-JONES or visit www.joneshollowrealty.com to start!